There’s an amusing moment in THE DESCENDANTS where George Clooney runs out his front door, and down a winding road to a neighbour’s house. What’s amusing, is that Clooney is running in a way we don’t often see in movies. He’s not jogging like someone keeping fit, and he’s not fleeing in an action scene. He’s running with a very human desperation and panic – and somehow it plays for laughs. It’s a rare sliver of urgent truth for moviegoers, and it’s a true beacon of the sort of honesty and humour so few movies offer.
THE DESCENDANTS begins by telling us that a Hawaiian resident named Elizabeth King was in a serious boating accident, leaving her in a coma. Her husband Matt King (George Clooney) is left to sit by her bedside and hope, while distracting himself with work and his newfound role as primary caregiver to the couple’s younger daughter Scottie (Amara Miller). What’s distracting him further is a massive land transfer he is working on with his extended family. They have been trusted with 25,000 acres of glorious, untouched land in Kaua’i, and the family has decided to sell a few years before the trust lapses.
Sadly, all of that is about to get a lot more difficult as Matt gets the news that Elizabeth likely will not wake from her coma. Armed with that terrible news, he goes to collect his oldest daughter Alexandra (Shailene Woodley) from boarding school. Alexandra is a bit rebellious, and not all that fussed about coming home, however when Matt tells her the news about her mother, she is grief-stricken, and begins the slow process of helping her dad carry out her mother’s wishes.
Before any of that can happen though, Alexandra reveals a secret to her father. Elizabeth was having an affair, as recently as a few months ago. the affair was the reason Alexandra and Elizabeth had a falling-out, and comes as a complete shock to Matt. Now conflicted with tending to a dying spouse who betrayed him, Matt decides to seek out the truth…knowing that he won’t be able to move forward with what needs to be done, until he can understand what has already happened.
THE DESCENDANTS is the sort of film I wish Hollywood made more often. It brings together a wonderful blend of drama, sorrow, and humour in a way that makes you feel like you of your fill of each. I shouldn’t really be all that surprised, since director Alexander Payne has proved to be a true pro at this sort of film thanks to SIDEWAYS, ABOUT SCHMIDT and ELECTION. It’s premise very easily could have played very mopey, or too screwball, but it finds a way to make everything feel very human – no easy trick with such a capital-M-movie star in the lead role.
On the page, the notion of a dying wife & mother who was unfaithful almost seems like melodrama. However, THE DESCENDANTS is able to make it very human by showing just what sort of natural ripples are created by this stone dropping in the water. In reality, there would be deep, difficult decisions on how to handle this sort of situation – for instance who to tell and how to tell them. I’m a believer that honesty is the best policy, but there’s always a course that has to be navigated, and sometimes holding on to the truth can be just as difficult as revealing it. To this end, Clooney and Woodley are tremendous in the way that they carry the burden of truth. They are both heartbreaking when withholding it, and quite genuine when revealing it.
As Matt King, Clooney especially underlines what it takes to try and keep one’s self together under such strain. He gives us glimpses of the wild amount of stress he’s under between the brutal triple-play of his dying wife, the land transaction, and become a more prominent father. And as is to be expected, they are only glimpses. He wouldn’t spend a week on the couch drowning his sorrows in alcohol, he wouldn’t pull away and weep for what has happened to him. Even if he wanted to, he doesn’t have that luxury with so much responsibility in the matter. Therefore the way Clooney makes the most of those brief moments he gets to surrender to his stress is heartbreaking: Not in what we see, but in how briefly we see it.
Of course, the most immediate reason for Matt’s brevity of grief is in how he needs to step up his fathering skills in a hurry. In many families, there’s a parent that leads and a parent that follows. It often hinges on one parents relationship with their job, which unfortunately can lead to a fractured relationship with their own children. Matt, Alexandra, and Scottie are wonderful to watch in this regard, since they spend much of the movie trying to set things right. Quite often, things don’t go all that well – Matt gets short-tempered and/or the girls get disrespectful. But slowly we are able to see the effort on all sides. It isn’t pretty, and it will obviously still be a process, but it leaves us feeling encouraged by small victories. Matt, Alexandra, and Scottie will likely never be the same – but one hopes they can evolve into something better.
Sometimes as descendants we are tasked with honouring those who have come before us. Our responsibility can be grand, like tending to property or legacy. The responsibility can also be deeply personal, such as keeping both those we never met and those we know and love close in heart as we make our choices. It’s never easy, and can sometimes mean that we’re living according to what someone else wants. But without these responsibilities…without roots…what would we have to keep us anchored. What would epitomize not just the place, but the feeling of home?
“Clooney and Woodley are tremendous in the way that they carry the burden of truth. They are both heartbreaking when withholding it, and quite genuine when revealing it.”
Well said. That should be on the movie poster, if you ask me.
Thanks dude…there moments during the writing of this that I was afraid I was babbling. Glad to know I hit the mark!
I think another reason why that running scene is kinda funny is because Clooney’s running in flip-flops – though IMO it’s not as funny as Thomas Hayden Church running naked down the street in ‘Sideways.’
Come to think of it, there’s a funny running scene in ELECTION too. Maybe Payne just gets that people running full-out in inherently funny!
I thought, for what it did, that this might be the film of the year. But, we’ve still got a month, don’t we? 😉
I’ve heard a few people call it the movie of the year. I have a cluster that ranked higher for me, but were this to be the consensus ‘numero uno’, I’d be alright with that.
As for what could still usurp it, there’s only a small cache left for me to see (namely DRAGON TATTOO, WAR HORSE, EXTREMELY LOUD, and THE IRON LADY). A few of those might shuffle the deck for me somewhat, but I think I know how my take on 2011 will shake down.
I was actually most impressed with Sid, and I was really surprised by that. I had heard really good things about Woodley and Clooney is always a contender, but Sid and the night scene, I thought was great.
Dude! Haven’t heard from you in ages – how’s things?
Sid was pretty damned awesome, and I now think I should have dedicated a few more words to him. That scene between him and Matt in the dead of night was indeed the sort of warm, intelligent dialogue I go to the movies in search of.
Viva Sid!
You my sir are correct. I however, believe you are incorrect in mentioning Election (even if it’s just to throw out the filmmaker’s cannon) in this review. The films tackle differing opinions in differing ways. This is a film of honesty, Election is a cynical look at people in a specific setting.
It’s a great film. To think last year Clooney spent 2 hours confidently handing out bad news in UP IN THE AIR, and now he’s doing ti with such vulnerability here.
All four of Payne’s films seem to have very different views on life. So you’re right – for the most part, ELECTION and DESCENDANTS couldn’t be less similar.
The only reason I mentioned it in the post (which I do stand by), is the fact that both films are funny, dramatic, and intelligent in a way mainstream Hollywood seems to have trouble achieving.
I think this shows that Payne isn’t really capable of making a bad movie– maybe movies that aren’t up to snuff against his best, but bad ones? No way. That said, I think The Descendants can rival his best work (which is sort of a hard distinction to make given how small his body of work is), though it’s very different from his other pictures.
What makes it work so well, and what you highlight so adroitly in your review, is that balance between the heavy and lighter tonality. Matt’s in a bit of an emotional crisis and yet we can still laugh at him running to his friends’ house in his sandals without feeling like heels.
Most of all The Descendants comes back to family and what really constitutes a family. For Matt, that ends up being the two daughters he doesn’t really know more than the cousins he clearly has a stronger connection to. At the end of the day, Scottie and Alexandra are there for Matt despite their issues; the cousins, represented by Beau Bridges, aren’t, favoring a relationship with Matt in which they can keep a knife to his back in case he doesn’t do what they want.
Woodley and Clooney are fantastic here, but I think Woodley surprised me the most.
I’m really enjoying seeing how well this film is being received, and can only anticipate what it will do as it widens out its release in the coming weeks.
We talk about it on the next episode of The Matineecast (subcribed to the new feed yet?) and how it fits in with Alexander payne’s overall body of work. My guest and I had differing opinions on the matter, but we both really enjoyed the film.
Great review! I thought this one was good but not great. I didn’t feel the shifts between humor and pathos were so smooth. The acting was stellar, though. Clooney’s was one of my favorite performances of the year.